一座山 is his life and someone also here likes it.

送交者: psychina 于 2008-04-18, 13:50:39:

Your 生活 is the 生活,NOT the one in other's eye.
You are the 生活, your reality, your inner world,your thinking, your mood, your future, your past, all together, is your life.

所有跟贴:

批评4：以血腥和百姓的愚昧取胜，格调低下。 (无内容) - 聊斋3 (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:31:47 (219237)
ZT：批评2 - 聊斋3 (540 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:24:10 (219229)
- trauma could be identical - psychina (61 bytes) 2008-04-18, 15:12:54 (219280)
批评1： - 聊斋3 (2200 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:20:06 (219223)
- 辅导阅读 - fishn (508 bytes) 2008-04-18, 15:12:03 (219279)
- 不合常识！literature has its own norm. (无内容) - psychina (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 15:06:19 (219272)
《一座山》不管被你们抬多高，我坚定地认为那是一堆文字垃圾堆 - JFF (73 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:15:57 (219220)
- never try to convince everybody - psychina (20 bytes) 2008-04-18, 15:08:34 (219274)
  - 我纳闷的是，新语丝的评委怎么会被这么弱智的胡编乱造给CONVINED了。 (无内容) - JFF (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 17:52:02 (219363)
- 从看过的第一章来说，基本上每个主要场景都是侮辱读者智力的胡编乱造。 (无内容) - JFF (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:49:21 (219253)
- 坚决支持一座山获奖 - fishn (129 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:22:04 (219226)
  - 批评3：打了无数枪还不倒，人死了眼还放光，宣扬迷信！ (无内容) - 聊斋3 (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:28:52 (219235)
  - 没读过余华，请直接讲讲好在哪里。 (无内容) - JFF (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:25:00 (219230)
    - 象讲故事似的娓娓道来，让你听得如醉如痴。 - fishn (116 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:32:11 (219238)
      - 真新鲜！小说不像讲故事似的难道像推导公式？ - JFF (52 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:47:57 (219251)
        
        二等奖三等奖的小说都不能作到这一点。 - fishn (16 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:59:26 (219262)
We are talking about the TEXT of <一座山>, not about "his life"! (无内容) - JFF (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:11:28 (219217)
- His life is in the text (无内容) - psychina (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:54:11 (219257)
correct. but readers and writers are in titled to know the merits - 聊斋3 (31 bytes) 2008-04-18, 13:57:34 (219195)
- entitlement is irrelevant to this private decision (无内容) - psychina (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:03:10 (219205)
  - do you call this awarding activity private? (无内容) - 聊斋3 (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:10:59 (219216)
    - by nature of XYS, yes (无内容) - psychina (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:52:45 (219255)
      - then you may also call CNN's comments private ... (无内容) - 聊斋3 (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:57:26 (219260)
        
        you could do whatever you want to CNN but nothing to do - psychina (17 bytes) 2008-04-18, 15:02:16 (219265)
        
        correct. our reaction is what we are entitled to - 聊斋3 (150 bytes) 2008-04-18, 15:14:18 (219281)
        
        what I meant is XYS doesn't have to respond to your - psychina (8 bytes) 2008-04-18, 15:17:28 (219286)
- 你只批判它有多烂就可以了。得奖的事情有别的因素俺们不知道。 (无内容) - Amsel (0 bytes) 2008-04-18, 14:00:46 (219201)

加跟贴